How much
"computing" do you need?
by Rick
Bushnell, President of Quad II
Note: A version of this article appeared
in the January, 1998 issue of Modern
Materials Handling magazine.
I was talking to a friend of mine, the CEO of
a pretty good sized company. He had just been to an executive briefing on
"Enterprise Computing." As part of the presentation, the CEO was told
that the first step was to hire a good consulting firm (Guess who sponsored the
event?) to review every aspect of his business.
The CEO saw a problem; to do the job right
would take about a year. He knew that his overhead was already eating him alive.
And his vice president of distribution wanted
a new warehouse management system; his vice president of sales and marketing was
hot on the idea of something called "vendor managed inventory," VMI.
VMI would require a sound EDI/Internet
platform and a complete revamp of the sales analysis, master scheduling, and
order entry systems. It would even impact the CEO's purchasing group and its
contacts with suppliers.
And what else? Our CEO said his Chairman of
the Board told him that a golfing buddy thought the only way to survive the next
10 years was to install an extremely comprehensive enterprise system.
The CEO looked at me somewhat bewildered and
remarked, "If the chairman knew what it takes to implement that system,
he'd give up golf!"
Then the CEO looked at me and said, "So
that bar code stuff you are always talking to me about will just have to
wait."
I didn't have the heart to tell the CEO about
all the transaction data that an enterprise computing system needs and that if
one manually key enters all that data--rather than using bar codes or other
forms of automatic data collection--he'll either go broke from the costs or
build a huge data base full of inaccurate data.
In his frustration, my friend, in a few
sentences and two big breaths, had identified the real problem. It isn't enough
to just know about the new concepts. You have to understand the relationships
between new technical capabilities and concepts and the business practices that
they permit or require.
So if understanding these relationships is the
issue, what's the solution? Here's your homework: Try to find answers to some
fundamental questions (see box) with your management team. I'll be addressing
them in this column over the next year and posting relevant comments from
readers at the web site.
Checklist for corporate computerization:
Before making decisions on hardware/software
for data capture, warehouse management, or even enterprise computing, try asking
these questions of management team members:
1. Is my company at the top, bottom, or middle
of a supply chain? What does that position mean to the purchasing, manufacturing
side of my operation? And what is the impact on the sales, marketing, and
distribution side?
2. If I need to ""reinvent'' my
company, what do I do about the market share and profits I lose while inventors
are reinventing me?
3. Where do data capture, document management,
and electronic commerce fit into my business?
4. How do I prioritize the changes that I know
I must make?
5. What's the fastest way to find out what I
need to know?
6. How can I ensure successful deployment of
technology?
7. Enterprise computing--what does that really
mean? Are complex systems the only way to get there?
8. How do I balance and even leverage
improvements to work flow (paper work) and material flow?